
It is just such a journey he takes us on in evaluating the Hall of Fame credentials of Dwight Evans. In a thoroughly "geeky", yet engaging, article he lays out the case for Dewey's overdue enshrinement in Cooperstown. Using his famous "Win-Shares" methodology (which estimates a player's contribution to his team's wins), James makes a convincing case that Evans (pictured here at a BoSox Club luncheon) meets or exceeds the threshold in career "win-shares" to make it in. Comparing his career to contemporary right-fielders (Winfield, Cedeno, Burroughs, Parker), we clearly see that Dewey (who atypically peaked in this thirties) deserves the honor. It is a argument that is hard to refute.