
Doumit has had injury woes, is a defensive "work-in-progress" and would cost Boston over $5 million. But how much is the post-season worth to Theo and The Trio? He is hitting above .270 this year and has thrown out 31% of runners. Decent on both counts—and he's only 30 years old. The Sox can't continue to overwork a nearly 40-year old catcher while hoping that Salty "comes around".
All things considered, a trade for Doumit (parting with some middle infield talent like Scutaro or a prospect) seems to make sense.